Wednesday, 15 July 2020
Upward extension of certain blocks of flats
The one change to the GPDO that got all the journos excited was the long-anticipated introduction of a permitted development right to extend certain blocks of flats by the addition of up to two extra floors. With effect from 1 August 2020, this will be enshrined in the new Part 20 of the Second Schedule to the GPDO. [Some indication of future intentions can be gleaned from the fact that the overall title of Part 20 is “Construction of New Dwellinghouses”, and that the addition of “new dwellinghouses on detached blocks of flats” comprises Class A in this Part of the Second Schedule. One may reasonably surmise that another Class, which may be added to Part 20 later this year, will comprise the demolition of existing buildings and the construction of new dwellings on the site, although the precise mechanism governing this has yet to be revealed, and may still be the subject of some debate within MHCLG.]
The development permitted by Class A of Part 20 consists of works for the construction of up to two additional storeys of “new dwellinghouses” (i.e. flats) immediately above the existing topmost residential storey on a building which is a purpose-built, detached block of flats, together with any or all engineering operations reasonably necessary to construct the additional storeys and new flats, as well as works for the replacement of existing plant or installation of additional plant on the roof of the extended building reasonably necessary to service the new flats, works for the construction of appropriate and safe access and egress to the new and existing flats, including means of escape from fire, via additional external doors or external staircases, and works for the construction of storage, waste or other ancillary facilities reasonably necessary to support the new flats.
“Block of flats” means a building which is divided horizontally and consists of separate and self-contained premises constructed for use for the purposes of a dwelling, and any ancillary facilities constructed solely for use by occupiers of the building; and “purpose-built” means a building that was built as and remains as a block of flats. “Detached” means that the building does not share a party wall with a neighbouring building; and “flat” means separate and self-contained premises constructed for use for the purposes of a dwelling.
These definitions in paragraph C of Part 20 represent significant constraints on the types of building that can be extended under Class A. So, for example, if the existing flats were created by converting an existing house, this building cannot be extended under Class A (because the building was not purpose-built as a block of flats). Similarly, the building must be free-standing, so if it is attached in any way to any other building, it cannot be extended under Class A. The definition of a “flat” also excludes any dwelling that was created by a change of use from any other use; it must have been constructed for residential use in the first place.
In addition to the restricted scope of permitted development under Class A, as a result of the definitions set out in paragraph C, Paragraph A.1 of Class A prohibits development under this PD right in in a variety of specified ways. First, development is not permitted by Class A if the permission to use any building as a dwelling or dwellings was granted only by virtue of Class M, N, O, P, PA or Q of Part 3 (i.e. residential conversion of various buildings under Part 3). [It seems somewhat unlikely that a detached block of flats will have been created as PD under Classes M, N, P, PA or Q, but it is entirely possible that a detached block of flats may have been created under Class O, and further extension of such a building under Part 20 is therefore precluded. Strictly speaking, this prohibition in paragraph A.1 is unnecessary, because any building containing flats created by the conversion of an existing building falls outside the definition of a ‘purpose-built flat’ in paragraph C.]
Paragraph A.1 also prohibits development under Class A if the building is less than 3 storeys in height above ground level. [I think we may take it that this means actual ground level, not the storey comprising the ground floor of the building; so any building that is less than three storeys high (not four) is excluded.]. Development is also excluded if the building was constructed before 1st July 1948, or after 5th March 2018. Furthermore, development is not permitted by Class A if the additional storeys are constructed other than on the principal part of the building. (“Principal part” means the main part of the building excluding any front, side or rear extension of a lower height, whether this forms part of the original building or a subsequent addition.)
Development under Class A is also prohibited if the floor to ceiling height of any additional storey, measured internally, is more than the floor to ceiling height of any of the existing storeys, or more than 3 metres in height (whichever is the lesser). It is also prohibited if the new dwellings are not flats, i.e. if they extend over more than one storey.
There is also an overall height limit. The overall height of the roof of the extended building must not be greater than 7 metres higher than the highest part of the existing roof (not including existing plant); and the building as a whole, as extended (but not including plant), must not be greater than 30 metres in height. There are also limitations with regard to support structures. The engineering operations required to construct the additional storeys, and the new flats, must not include the provision of visible support structures on or attached to the exterior of the building upon completion of the development. Such engineering operations are in any event restricted to works within the existing curtilage of the building to strengthen existing walls, to strengthen existing foundations, or to install or replace water, drainage, electricity, gas or other services. Engineering operations falling outside these parameters are prohibited.
Works for the replacement of existing plant or installation of additional plant on the roof of the extended building reasonably necessary to service the new flats are not permitted if there is no existing plant on the building. In the case of new or replacement plant, the height of such new or additional plant as measured from the lowest surface of the new roof on the principal part of the new building must not exceed the height of any existing plant as measured from the lowest surface of the existing roof on the principal part of the existing building.
Any works for the construction of access to the new and existing flats, including fire escapes, via additional external doors or external staircases, must not extend beyond the curtilage of the existing building. [‘Curtilage’ for this purpose is not defined, and so the generally accepted definition of the word should be applied – see Sinclair Lockhart’s Trustees, Dyer v Dorset CC, Skerritts of Nottingham, etc.] Any works for the construction of storage, waste or other ancillary facilities for the new flats must not extend beyond the curtilage of the existing building, nor must any part of them be situated on land forward of a wall forming the principal elevation of the existing building, or be situated on land forward of a wall fronting a highway and forming a side elevation of the existing building.
Development under Class A is also prohibited if the land or site on which the building is located, is or forms part of, “Article 2(3) land” (i.e. a Conservation Area, an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, the Broads, a National Park or a World Heritage Site). [The exclusions in Article 2(3) also apply to any area specified by the Secretary of State for the purposes of section 41(3) of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended by sections 20 and 24 of, and Schedules 3 and 4 to, the Agriculture Act 1986, Schedule 3 to the Norfolk and Suffolk Broads Act 1988, Schedule 10 to the Environment Act 1995 and Schedules 11 and 12 to the Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006), relating to enhancement and protection of the natural beauty and amenity of the countryside. However, I am not aware of any such areas ever having been so specified.]
The prohibition of development also extends to a Site of Special Scientific Interest, a listed building or land within its curtilage, a scheduled monument or land within its curtilage, a safety hazard area, a military explosives storage area; or land within 3 kilometres of the perimeter of an aerodrome. The definitions of “safety hazard area” and “military explosives storage area” are explained in the Third Edition of my book, A Practical Guide to Permitted Changes of Use.
I think readers will agree that the combined effect of the definitions in paragraph C and the prohibitions in paragraph A.1 significantly cut down on the number of buildings that can in practice be extended under Class A of Part 20.
In addition to the restrictions discussed above, this PD right is hedged around with various conditions, the most important of which is a requirement to make a prior approval application before beginning the development (and, of course, await its determination). The matters that may require the LPA’s prior approval are:
(a) transport and highways impacts of the development;
(b) air traffic and defence asset impacts of the development;
(c) contamination risks in relation to the building;
(d) flooding risks in relation to the building;
(e) the external appearance of the building;
(f) the provision of adequate natural light in all habitable rooms of the new flats
(g) impact on the amenity of the existing building and neighbouring premises including overlooking, privacy and the loss of light; and
(h) whether because of the siting of the building, the development will impact on a protected view identified in the Directions Relating to Protected Vistas dated 15 March 2012 issued by the Secretary of State. [This is a reference to the following online document: https://www.london.gov.uk/what-we-do/planning/implementing-london-plan/planning-guidance-and-practice-notes/londonview-Management]
A “defence asset” is a site identified on a safeguarding map provided to the LPA for the purposes of a direction made by the Secretary of State in exercise of the powers conferred by article 31(1) of the Procedure Order or any previous powers to the like effect. [This refers to Joint Circular 01/2003 issued on 27th January 2003 by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.]
“Technical sites” has the same meaning as in Annexe 1 of the Town and Country Planning (Safeguarded Aerodromes, Technical Sites and Military Explosives Storage Areas) Direction 2002. [This too can be found in Circular 01/2003.]
The definition of “habitable rooms” is set out in paragraph C, and is the same as the definition that has been added to Part 3. (See my recent post, dealing with those changes, where I pointed out that a kitchen does not have to have adequate natural light, whereas a kitchen/diner does, with a resulting risk of disputes as to the correct identification of such a room, if it has no or limited natural light.)
Note that, in contrast to other PD rights relating to residential development under the GPDO, overlooking, privacy and the loss of light are all issues to be considered in the case of this Class of permitted development. The provision of adequate natural light in all habitable rooms of the new flats is an issue that must also be considered, but other aspects of residential amenity are not subject to prior approval. So, for example, the LPA is not entitled to consider the adequacy of the accommodation in spatial terms.
In order to ensure that the prior approval application is validly made, it is essential that the applicant complies strictly with all of the requirements set out in paragraph B of Part 20. The application must be accompanied by—
(a) a written description of the proposed development, which, in relation to development proposed under Class A, must include details of any flat and other works proposed under paragraphs A(a) to (d) (i.e. engineering operations for the construction of the additional storeys and new flats, works for the replacement of existing plant or installation of additional plant on the roof, works for access, fire escape, etc. and works for the construction of storage, waste or other ancillary facilities)
(b) a plan drawn to an identified scale and shows the direction of North indicating the site and showing the proposed development;
(c) floor plans drawn to an identified scale and show the direction of North indicating the dimensions and proposed use of each room, the position and dimensions of windows, doors and walls, and the existing and proposed elevations of the building;
(d) a written statement specifying the number of new flats proposed by the development that is additional to the number of flats in the building immediately prior to development;
(e) a list of all addresses of the flats within the existing block of flats;
(f) the developer’s contact address;
(g) the developer’s email address if the developer is content to receive communications electronically; and
(h) where there is a requirement [see below] the Environment Agency to be consulted, a site-specific flood risk assessment,
together with any fee required to be paid [see below].
For the first time, there is a requirement for the submitted plans to be drawn to an identified scale and show the direction of North. (N.B. This requirement still does not apply to applications under Part 3.) Despite the requirement to provide plans indicating the dimensions and proposed use of each room, and the position and dimensions of windows, doors and walls, the only issue the LPA can consider is the adequacy of natural light in those rooms that are defined as habitable rooms; they cannot refuse the application in relation to any other aspect of residential amenity such as the adequacy of the accommodation in spatial terms.
As regards the payment of an application fee, Regulation 14 of the 2012 Fees Regs will be amended to provide that the application fee payable on a prior approval application for new flats created under Part 20 of the Second Schedule to the GPDO will be £334 for each flat, where less than 50 are to be created in accordance with the prior approval for which application is being made. Where the number of new flats proposed in this prior approval application is more than 50, the fee will be £16,525, plus £100 for each new flat in excess of 50, subject to a maximum fee of £300,000.
However, the new fees will not be in place when Part 20 comes into effect on 1 August. The change is intended to be made by the Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) Regulations 2020. For the time being, these are draft regulations, which are subject to approval by a resolution in both the Commons and the Lords before they are made. They will come into force on the 28th day after they are made. It seems, therefore, that if canny developers can get their act together quickly, they may be able to bang in a prior approval application under Part 20 in the first half of August absolutely free, gratis and for nothing. This is confirmed by Regulation 3 of the draft fee regs amendment, so that no fee is payable in respect of a prior approval application under Regulation 14(1)(c) (i.e. an application under Part 20) if the application is made before the date on which the amended fee regulations come into force.
It is the much higher application fees that will apply to prior approval applications for developments under Part 20 that has prompted a proposed change to the Fees Regs to allow a ‘free go’ on a second prior approval application under Part 20. Regulation 2(3) will introduce for the first time a ‘free go’ for a second prior approval application for permitted development under Part 20, thus bringing the fees regs for this type of prior approval application into line with those that apply to planning applications. This ‘free go’ for a second prior approval application, however, will apply only to applications under Part 20. There continues to be no ‘free go’ for second applications under other Parts of the Second Schedule to the GPDO.
Before looking at other conditions attached to PD under Part 20, I’ll deal briefly with the procedural requirements for the consideration and determination of prior approval applications under Part 20. Unsurprisingly, these are substantially similar to the rules applying to applications under Part 3. Rather than repeating these in detail, I would simply refer readers to Chapter 14 of the Third Edition of A Practical Guide to Permitted Changes of Use. In addition to those rules, where the application relates to prior approval as to the impact on air traffic or defence assets, the LPA must consult in addition any relevant operators of aerodromes, technical sites or defence assets and where appropriate the Civil Aviation Authority and the Secretary of State for Defence. Where an aerodrome, technical site or defence asset is identified on a safeguarding map provided to the LPA, the authority must not grant prior approval contrary to the advice of the operator of the aerodrome, technical site or defence asset, the Civil Aviation Authority or the Secretary of State for Defence.
As in the case of Part 3, where the application relates to prior approval as to natural light, the LPA must refuse prior approval if adequate natural light is not provided in all the habitable rooms of the flats. Where the application relates to prior approval as to the impact on protected views, the LPA must consult Historic England, the Mayor of London and any local planning authorities identified in the Directions Relating to Protected Vistas dated 15th March 2012 (referred to above).
In addition to posting a notice of the proposed development near the site, the LPA must also serve a notice on all owners and occupiers of the flats within the existing block of flats, and also on any adjoining owner or occupier. When determining the application, the LPA must take into account any representations made to them as a result of this consultation process (although the LPA can only take note of those representations that are addressed to the matters requiring prior approval, and must exclude from their consideration any representations that are addressed to other issues.)
When I originally published this post this afternoon, I wrote that there is no time limit for the determination of a prior approval application under Part 20. I had overlooked Article 7, which provides that where no period is specified as to the period within which a prior approval must be determined, it must be determined within a period of 8 weeks following the receipt of the application by the LPA. However, as I correctly stated, the “56-day rule” does NOT apply. The applicant is NOT entitled to proceed with their development in default of the determination of the prior approval application within the 8-week period. The development must not, therefore, begin before the receipt by the applicant from the LPA of a written notice giving their prior approval. The only remedy open to the developer in the event of non-determination within the 8-week period (or such longer period as may be agreed in writing by both parties) is an appeal under section 78 against such non-determination.
Any development under Class A is permitted subject to the condition that before beginning the development, the developer must provide the LPA with a report for the management of the construction of the development, setting out the proposed development hours of operation and how any adverse impact of noise, dust, vibration and traffic on occupiers of the building and adjoining owners or occupiers will be mitigated.
The development must be carried out in accordance with the details approved by the LPA and must be completed within a period of 3 years starting with the date on which prior approval is granted. Bearing in mind that the development permitted by Class 20 is built development (not a change of use), ‘completed’ means physically completed in this case; actual residential occupation is not required within the 3-year time limit. The test, I suggest, should be the same as the House of Lords proposed in Sage, even though that case itself was concerned with the interpretation of the term “substantially completed” in section 171B(1) for the purposes of the time limit for enforcement. The developer must notify the LPA of the completion of the development as soon as reasonably practicable after completion. This notification must be in writing and must include—
(a) the name of the developer;
(b) the address or location of the development; and
(c) the date of completion.
Any new flat created under Class A must remain in use as a dwellinghouse within the meaning of Class C3 and for no other purpose, except to the extent that the other purpose is ancillary to the primary use as a dwellinghouse.
There is, of course, power for the LPA to impose conditions on their prior approval. However, this does not give the LPA carte blanche to impose any conditions they please; the conditions must be reasonably related to the subject matter of the prior approval. The approval does not relate to the entirety of the proposed development, but only to those matters which are specified for approval under Class A of Part 20. It does not allow the imposition of more wide-ranging conditions of the kind that are frequently imposed on planning permissions.
In particular, it is not within the power of an LPA to impose conditions on a prior approval under Class A of Part 20 which seek the provision of, or any contribution to, affordable housing or any other form of financial contribution. Equally, an LPA cannot impose any conditions as to the provision of public open space, play areas and the like. It is not open to an LPA to impose a condition as to the time within which development must be commenced or completed, because this is already governed by paragraph A.2(2).
There is one final point that should be borne in mind, both by developers and by the residents of existing flats in any block that is affected by proposed development under Part 20. This relates to the law of landlord and tenant (and so is not a planning issue as such, and will not therefore be of concern to the LPA when considering and determining a prior approval application under Part 20). It may nevertheless be an important issue as between flat owners or occupiers and their landlord. Flat owners should take expert legal advice from an experienced property lawyer as to their legal position in relation to any such proposal. It will entirely depend on the terms of their lease as to whether they have any right to prevent the development, and so it is not a matter on which I can usefully comment in this blog, other than to flag it up as a matter of legitimate concern that may need to be addressed.
As to whether there will be a significant number of developments under Class A of Part 20, it very much depends on the practical effect of all the prohibitions, restrictions and conditions that govern these developments. As I have suggested above, they may prove to be a stumbling block in quite a few cases, and may reduce (perhaps to a substantial extent) the number of such developments that will in practice be carried out.
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Thursday, 9 July 2020
Latest changes to the GPDO
On 26 June, I drew attention to the temporary changes to the GPDO made by The Town and Country Planning (Permitted Development and Miscellaneous Amendments) (England) (Coronavirus) Regulations 2020 (SI 2020 No. 632). In addition to the new temporary PD rights that came into effect on 25 June, these Regulations make permanent changes to the GPDO. The title of this SI is, on the face of it, misleading because the permanent changes to the GPDO that will come into force on 1 August have nothing at all to do with the current coronavirus crisis.
The one change that grabbed the headlines was the introduction of a new Part 20 to the Second Schedule to the GPDO, which will permit the addition of two extra storeys to certain blocks of flats. However, I am not inclined to get too excited about this change, because I suspect that developers will find that the opportunities to avail themselves of this new PD right are, in practice, somewhat limited. I will return to Part 20 in a later post, but I want to concentrate today on the other changes to the GPDO that will take effect on 1 August.
The other changes fall broadly into three categories. First there is a belated tidying up of the drafting of Article 7 (relating to the agreed extension of time for determination of a prior approval application). Second, there are some minor consequential amendments to Part 1 in light of some of the other changes that have been made to the GPDO, and then third come a number of amendments to the drafting of the residential conversion provisions in Part 3 (Classes M, N, O, PA and Q) and also in paragraphs W and X, including an important change with regard to prior approval applications.
Most of us thought that Article 7 was quite clear in its intention and effect, namely that a prior approval application has to be determined within the period specified in the relevant Part of Sch. 2 (or, in the absence of a specified period, within 8 weeks), or within such longer period as may be agreed by the applicant and the authority in writing. But we then had the Warren Farm judgment which (much to everyone’s surprise) ruled that, in practice, time could not be extended by agreement. To general rejoicing, that judgment was reversed by Gluck, which established that Article 7 does mean what it appeared to say. Nevertheless, MHCLG has now decided to tweak the wording of Article 7 to put the matter beyond any possible dispute. Article 7 has now been amended to read that, as an alternative to (a) and (b), the prior approval application may be determined “within such longer period than is referred to in paragraph (a) or (b) as may be agreed by the applicant and the authority in writing.”
Turning to Part 1, an apparent gap in the legislation has now (rather belatedly) been plugged. Last year, the Fees Regs were amended so that prior approval applications for larger domestic extensions would be subject to the payment of a fee of £96. It was intended that this fee would be payable on prior approval applications under Part 1 that were made on or after 19 August 2019. However, MHCLG omitted to amend Part 1 in the Second Schedule to the GPDO to require that the items to be provided to the LPA in connection with a prior approval application must include “any fee required to be paid.”. I don’t know whether somebody took the point that there was no actual requirement in Part 1 itself to pay an application fee, but with effect from 1 August this apparent loophole will now be plugged by the requirement that the listed items must be provided “together with any fee required to be paid” (namely the amount stated in regulation 14(1)(zab) of the Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) Regulations 2012 (S.1. 2012/2920)). I wonder - Would it be open to anyone who had paid a £96 application fee under Part 1 between 19 August 2019 and 31 July 2020 to demand that the LPA refund that fee?
It is worth remembering that Reg. 14(1A) of the 2012 Fees Regs provides that no application fee is required for the prior approval application where an application fee is paid for a planning application made in respect of proposals for development of a site which includes buildings or other land which are the subject of the prior approval application, provided that the application for planning permission is made on the same date and by or on behalf of the same applicant as the prior approval application.
The conditions attached to Class B include a provision [B.2(b)(ii)] that other than in the case of an enlargement which joins the original roof to the roof of a rear or side extension, no part of the enlargement must extend beyond the outside face of any external wall of the original dwellinghouse. As originally drafted, paragraph B.4 provided that for the purposes of paragraph B.2(b)(ii), roof tiles, guttering, fascias, barge boards and other minor roof details overhanging the external wall of the original dwellinghouse were not to be considered part of the enlargement. This has now been amended, so that for these purposes (a) roof tiles, guttering, fascias, barge boards and other minor roof details overhanging the external wall of the original dwellinghouse are not to be considered part of the enlargement; and (b) “rear or side extension” includes an original part of, or a subsequent extension of the dwellinghouse that extends from the rear or side of the principal part of the original dwellinghouse.
The PD rights under all Classes in Part 1 are excluded in respect of any dwelling created under the new Part 20 (upward extensions of blocks of flats).
In Part 3, an important change is made in respect of prior approval applications relating to residential conversions under Classes M, N, O, PA and Q. In each of these Classes an additional matter will require approval, namely “the provision of adequate natural light in all habitable rooms of the dwellinghouses” so created. “Habitable rooms” are defined as “any rooms used or intended to be used for sleeping or living” which are not solely used for cooking purposes, (but does not include bath or toilet facilities, service rooms, corridors, laundry rooms, hallways or utility rooms). So a kitchen does not have to have adequate natural light, whereas a kitchen/diner does. There is clearly scope here for dispute as to whether the kitchen is solely provided for cooking purposes, and for no other purpose (such as eating, or informal entertainment of guests).
In addition, paragraph W has also been amended to require that in relation to prior approval applications in respect of any of these five Classes of residential conversion, the application must also be accompanied by “ a floor plan indicating the dimensions and proposed use of each room, the position and dimensions of windows, doors and walls, and the elevations of the dwellinghouses.” It was perhaps anomalous that this provision was not included in the original drafting. Notwithstanding this, however, the LPA is still not entitled to consider the adequacy of the accommodation in spatial terms; the only additional item that they can now consider is the adequacy of natural light in those rooms that are defined as habitable rooms.
Furthermore, where the application relates to prior approval as to adequate natural light, the LPA must refuse prior approval if adequate natural light is not provided in all the habitable rooms of the dwellinghouses. This is not a matter for the LPA’s discretion; refusal is mandatory in such circumstances. For the sake of good order, the LPA’s discretion under paragraph W(3) to refuse an application where the proposed development does not comply with any relevant conditions, limitations or restrictions applicable to the development permitted is removed in respect of the provision of adequate light in the case of Classes M, N, O, PA and Q, in view of the absolute requirement to refuse the application where adequate natural light is not provided in such a case.
The inclusion of Class PA in these amendments is puzzling, because paragraph PA.1 in Class PA provides that “Development is not permitted by Class PA if— (c) the prior approval date falls on or after 1st October 2020.” [The “prior approval date” is the date on which prior approval is given, or a determination is given that such approval is not required, and also if the period for giving such a determination (56 days in the case of Part 3) has expired without the applicant being notified whether prior approval is required, given or refused.] So it will only be possible for a few days after 1 August to submit a prior approval application under Class PA for determination in advance of the 1 October prior approval deadline. Are the government perhaps hedging their bets in case they might decide after all to extend Class PA, which they could still do between now and late September? This could possibly explain the otherwise inexplicable addition of sub-paragraph (v) to PA.2(1)(b)].
Some people seem to have been confused by the transitional provisions in Reg. 27. This provides that where a “prior approval event” occurs, the planning permission granted by Class M, N, O, PA or Q of Part 3 of Schedule 2 to the 2015 Order continues to have effect as if the amendments made by Part 2 of these Regulations [i.e. the amendments made by these Regs to the 2015 Order] had not been made. The only effect of this provision that I can discern is that [having regard to the definition of “prior approval event” in Reg. 27(1)] these changes do not have any effect in relation to any PD right in respect of which a prior approval application is either determined before 1 August [or the 56-day rule operates before that date, in the event of non-determination] or, alternatively, where the prior approval application is made before 1 August, but is determined after that date. In other words, the changes have effect only in respect of PD in respect of which a prior approval application is made on or after 1 August. [I really don’t understand why they couldn’t just have said this!]
As I read the new Regs, they do not amend or have any effect on paragraph PA.1(c), which continues to prohibit any PD under Class PA where the prior approval date falls on or after 1st October 2020. There is nothing in the new Regs that preserves or extends the PD right under Class PA for the residential conversion of a light industrial building. The guillotine will still fall on 1 October, and will rule out any PD under this Class where the prior approval date falls on or after that date.
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Friday, 26 June 2020
Further temporary changes to the GPDO
The Town and Country Planning (Permitted Development and Miscellaneous Amendments) (England) (Coronavirus) Regulations 2020 (SI 2020 No. 632) were made on 23 June. Most of these amendments come into force on 1 August, but Regulations 20 and 21 came into effect on 25 June. I will confine myself in this post to these two changes, and will discuss the other changes in a later post.
Regulation 20 introduces a new PD right for temporary changes of use in Part 4 of the Second Schedule to the GPDO. This is Class BA (additional temporary use of land). This PD right is additional to the 14/28 day uses permitted by Part 4, Class B. It is also additional to the temporary change of use permitted by Class BA of Part 12 (as to which see below). The development permitted is the use of any land, in addition to that permitted by Class B of Part 4, for any purposes for not more than 28 days in total during the period from 1 July 2020 to 31 December 2020, of which no more than 14 days in total may be for the purposes of the holding of a market, or for the purposes of motor car and motorcycle racing including trials of speed, and practising for these activities, and the provision on the land of any moveable structure for the purposes of the permitted use.
However, development is not permitted by Class BA of Part 4 if:
(a) the land in question is a building or is within the curtilage of a listed building;
(b) the use of the land is for a caravan site;
(c) the land is, or is within, a site of special scientific interest, and the use of the land is for motor car and motorcycle racing including trials of speed or other motor sports, and practising for these activities; clay pigeon shooting; or any war game, or
(d) the use of the land is for the display of an advertisement.
Regulation 21 introduces a new PD right in Part 12 of the Second Schedule. This is Class BA of that Part, which relates to the holding of a market by or on behalf of a local authority The development permitted is the use of any land for the purposes of holding a market by or on behalf of a local authority and the provision on the land of any moveable structure for the permitted use at any time during the period beginning with 25 June 2020 and ending with 23 March 2021.
Development is not permitted by Class BA of Part 12 if the land is, or is within, a site of special scientific interest.
I confess that the justification for the extra temporary PD rights outlined above has escaped me, other perhaps than a desire on the part of the government to provide more ‘bread and circuses’ for “the ordinary people” as the PM and his boss (D Cummings, Esq) are in the habit of calling us.
Although I'll be dealing with the rest of this SI in a future post, I should perhaps mention that other measures in these regulations are not related in any way to Coronavirus; nor are they temporary. These regulations contain some quite important changes to other PD rights. Watch this space!
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Thursday, 25 June 2020
Matters arising - Extension of time for prior approval
Following my webinar on Permitted Development at the end of last month, I was hoping to answer some of the questions that had been submitted, but which there was not time to answer ‘on the air’. Unfortunately, there has been some delay, due in part to our encountering a difficulty in actually downloading the questions from Zoom. In this post I shall concentrate on those questions that related to the extension of time for the determination of a prior approval application.
The first questioner asked whether an LPA’s refusal, despite Gluck, to agree an extended deadline for determination of a prior approval, might be unreasonable behaviour, and therefore grounds for a costs claim. However, one has to remember that the LPA is bound in principle to determine the prior approval application within the relevant time limit, failing which the PD right will be exercisable by default. It is therefore up to the LPA either to determine the prior approval within that deadline or to seek the agreement of the applicant to an extension of time. There is no requirement for an LPA to do this; Gluck merely confirmed that Article 7 of the GPDO does enable time to be extended by the written agreement of both parties.
If the LPA refuses the application within the time limit, rather than seeking an agreed extension of time, I suppose that (in some circumstances) this might amount to unreasonable behaviour justifying an award of costs, if it is clear that an agreed extension of time would have enabled them to grant prior approval. But I stress that this would be very much dependent on the facts of the case. If their refusal of prior approval was justified in any event, then clearly the fact that they did not seek agreement to an extension of time for their determination of the application would not be grounds for an award of costs.
Another questioner had forwarded my blog post on the extension of time limits to the LPA, but they declined to extend time on a Class Q application to enable a Phase 2 bat survey to be completed. A refusal was issued on the ground that incomplete bat survey information had been provided and also that the applicant had failed to sign a section 106 undertaking requiring a payment to be made to the LPA.
Taking the latter point first, I cannot envisage any circumstances in which any payment to the LPA could be required in respect of the matters requiring prior approval under the GPDO. So this would certainly be a potential ground of appeal (and would possibly justify an application for costs against the LPA). The question of the bat survey is, however, slightly more problematic. I am aware of prior approval appeals being dismissed for lack of information on ecological issues (such as a bat survey where this might reasonably be required). On the other hand, I am aware of a condition being imposed on a prior approval granted on appeal requiring a bat survey before the commencement of the permitted development. The questioner might have been justified in expecting this approach to be taken; alternatively, an extension of time could perhaps have been agreed. If an appeal were to be lodged against the refusal of prior approval, there might possibly be time to complete a Phase 2 bat survey, and forward this to the Inspector, although I am not sure whether such ‘late’ information would be accepted by PINS. A better option might be to start again with a fresh prior approval application, having first completed the bat survey.
The next question was - "If an LPA does not determine a Class Q application within 56 days, should they issue a letter to the applicant confirming that they have deemed consent if the proposal is permitted development; or refuse to determine the application and advise the applicant to apply for a Lawful Development Certificate for a determination as to whether it is permitted development?"
I am not convinced that an LPA that misses the deadline for determination is specifically required to do anything. They have missed the boat and, provided the development does actually qualify as PD, the developer is free to proceed with the development. I have always advised developers that they need to be quite sure that the development does qualify as PD and that it does meet all the limitations, restrictions and conditions that apply to that particular development. If there is any doubt about this, or if it is clear that the LPA does not accept that the development does in fact qualify as PD, then it may be advisable to apply for a Certificate as to the Lawfulness of Proposed Use or Development under section 192 before starting work. A gung-ho approach on the part of the developer could be risky unless they have been advised by professional consultants that the development undoubtedly qualifies as PD. The onus is entirely on the developer to satisfy themselves as to the legal position; it really doesn’t matter whether the LPA sends a belated communication or not.
There was then a question as to whether conditions 'bite' when the LPA issues a prior approval after the expiry of the determination period. The answer to this is that, once the deadline has passed, any notice issued by the LPA will be of no legal effect, even a purported notice of approval. It follows that any conditions attached to a purported prior approval issued out of time will be of no effect.
A different aspect of this issue was raised with regard to Part 6, Class A - Although the Order specifies a timeframe for the Council to notify the applicant if prior approval is required, there is no timeframe for the submission of the prior approval details (when they are required), or for the Council to then give or refuse approval of those details. Do the time limits in Article 7 therefore apply to the 'second stage' of the application? The wording would suggest the 8 weeks would run from the date of the application, i.e. the first stage, not the second stage, however the prior approval details may not be submitted within that timeframe. Is there anywhere else in the legislation that would put a time limit on the second stage decision?
This would appear to be a lacuna in the legislation. The LPA must decide within 28 days whether their prior approval will be required as to the siting, design and external appearance of the building, etc. The initial prior approval application will have been accompanied by a written description of the proposed development and of the materials to be used and a plan indicating the site, but if the LPA does decide (within the 28-day period) that their prior approval of siting, design, etc, will be required, there may well be a need for more information (such as building elevations, etc.) to be provided. There is no indication as to when the developer should provide this information, nor is there any binding obligation on the LPA to approve the siting, design, etc. within any particular period. The usual 8-week period allowed for the determination of planning applications would appear to apply in principle, but the only remedy for the developer if that further 8-week period expires without a decision would be an appeal against non-determination (deemed refusal). Most applicants would no doubt prefer to wait and see whether an approval is in fact forthcoming.
Finally, a questioner asks whether an extension of time can be agreed with the applicant via email or whether it must be in the form of a letter. This question arose in Gluck. The judge held that an email qualifies as being “in writing”, and no greater formality of communication is required.
I will deal with some questions on Class Q and other particular classes of PD in a future post.
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Wednesday, 24 June 2020
Planning permissions to be extended
A few weeks ago correspondents raised in comments on this blog their concern about planning permissions expiring during the current coronavirus crisis without developers being able to commence their development within the time limit specified in the permission.
The Scottish Government tackled this problem some time ago – one of the many examples of the superior performance of Scottish ministers compared with the hapless and hopeless crew appointed by Boris Johnson.
Now Mr R Jenrick (who is believed to be the Hosing and Communities Secretary, at least for the time being) has at last got around to announcing a similar relaxation in England although, typically, the announcement, only in the form of a deliberately vague press release, fails to give any details of exactly how this will work.
We still don’t know the legal mechanism by which the life of planning permissions will be extended. It appears that the relaxation of the time limit for the implementation of planning permission will apply to all permissions expiring since the imposition of the coronavirus lockdown in late March. So does this mean that planning permissions that have expired within the past three months will be retrospectively revived?
I think we all ought to be told exactly what the government is doing about this, rather than having to rely on a half-baked and largely uninformative press release. Maybe Jenrick has been too busy worrying about legal challenges to unlawful planning permissions to Tory donors, or about getting planning permission for a big extension of his Westminster town house, after it was previously rejected on planning grounds by the LPA’s officers. Must try harder.(Or maybe just resign)
UPDATE [25.6.20]: I am grateful to Richard W and Steve Jupp for drawing the Business and Planning Bill to my attention (see comments below). So this is how the government intends to enable time for commencement to be extended. The Bill is in fact the vehicle for various planning and licensing relaxations that have recently been canvassed. The problem is that it is only a Bill (which has only just had its First Reading [a mere formality] today and is yet to begin its passage through both Houses in parliament). It seems that the government intends to fast-track the Bill through the Commons (with all stages being taken next Monday, 29 June) but they have less control over what happens in the Lords.
Clause 17 of the Bill introduces sections 93A and 93B into the 1990 Act. Section 93A substitutes a commencement condition specifying 1 April 2021 as the commencement date in place of a condition in an unimplemented planning permission. However, section 93A is not retrospective in its effect. This section only applies to planning permissions where the original commencement date specified by the condition in the planning permission will expire within the period beginning with the day on which section 17 of the Business and Planning Act 2020 comes into force [as yet unknown] and ending with 31 December 2020.
For those planning permissions that will already have lapsed before the Act comes into effect, section 93B provides a somewhat more complex procedure. It applies where the date for commencement of development falls within the period beginning with 23 March 2020, and ending with the day before the date on which section 17 of the Business and Planning Act 2020 comes into force. This involves the developer in applying for an “additional environmental approval”. If this approval is granted, this too will substitute a commencement condition specifying 1 April 2021 as the commencement date in place of a commencement condition in the unimplemented planning permission.
The precise requirements for an application for an “additional environmental approval” are too complicated to summarise here, but they cover the need for EIA, compliance with the Habitats Directive, and other environmental protections. There does not appear, however, to be any requirement for the application to be determined in accordance with section 38(6) of the 2004 Act. Furthermore, no conditions can be imposed on the additional environmental approval.
My initial impression is that what is now proposed is going to be unduly complicated and too slow, and will involve developers in jumping through hoops to enable planning permissions to be extended. No doubt the complications of section 93B were thought necessary in order to ensure compliance with the relevant environmental protections, merely by reason of the original planning permission having lapsed, but I find it hard to believe that extending the date for commencement of development by less than 9 months would give rise to any fresh environmental considerations, especially when other permissions expiring a little later will not be subject to the requirement for additional environmental approval.
I had always thought that primary legislation might be required to enable the time limits as to commencement of development to be varied. But there were surely simpler ways the government could have gone about this. For example, section 73(5) of the 1990 Act could simply be have been repealed (or its operation suspended for a stated period), enabling a section 73 application to be made to vary the time by which development must be started, or the time by which an application for the approval of reserved matters must be made. If this variation were to be allowed retrospectively, section 75(4) would have to be similarly repealed or suspended.
This would still make it necessary for the developer to make an application to the LPA, but doing this under section 73 would appear to be more straightforward than what is proposed in the new Bill.
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Tuesday, 16 June 2020
Compulsory closure of premises – revised rules
The Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (England) (Amendment) (No. 4) Regulations 2020 (SI 2020 No. 588) are now in force. They further amend the Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (England) Regulations 2020 (S.I. 2020/350). I have not previously commented on the No.3 amendment regulations (S.I. 2020/558), which came into force on 1 June, and so I will cover those as well in this note. However, I shall confine this summary to those regulations that govern the use of premises; I am not therefore commenting on those regulations that continue to govern personal movement.
Where various premises have previously been required to be closed, the proprietor of a business offering goods for sale or for hire can now open it to the public, provided the shop is separate from the premises used for any business that is still required to remain closed. So all shops can now open to the public. “Shops” are not defined in the Regulations, and so it would seem that the definition in Class A1 of the Schedule to the Use Classes Order 1987 (as amended) can be assumed to apply. As before, such businesses are also permitted to make deliveries or otherwise provide services in response to orders received through a website, or otherwise by on-line communication, or by telephone (including orders by text message), or by post.
Again, as before, a café or restaurant may be open solely to sell food or drink for consumption off the premises, provided the café or restaurant is separate from any premises used for a business that is still required to remain closed. For this purpose, a shop, café or restaurant is separate from premises used for the closed business if it is in a self-contained unit, and provided also that it is possible for a member of the public to enter the shop or café from a place outside those closed premises. The list of catering premises that must otherwise remain closed remains the same as it was in Part 1 of Schedule 2 in the original regulations.
There are slight changes to Part 2 of Schedule 2, comprising the list of other premises that must remain closed. Drive-in cinemas are now exempted from the requirement to close cinemas. The prohibition on opening museums and galleries no longer extends to retail galleries, where the majority of the art on display is for sale. (These are galleries that fall in fact within Use Class A1, rather than D1). Betting shops are no longer required to remain closed.
On the other hand, the prohibition on the opening of indoor fitness studios, gyms, swimming pools, bowling alleys, amusement arcades or soft play areas or other indoor leisure centres or facilities was extended by the No.3 amendment Regs (on 1 June) to include indoor games, recreation and entertainment venues. Similarly, the prohibition on the opening of funfairs (whether outdoors or indoors) has been extended by the No.3 Amendment Regs to embrace theme parks and adventure parks and activities. These were clearly unintended omissions from the original Regs. For the same reason the prohibition on opening playgrounds etc. has now been tweaked twice, and it now prohibits the opening of playgrounds, indoor sports courts, outdoor gyms and outdoor swimming pools. The listed prohibitions have also been extended to social clubs, model villages and indoor attractions (as defined in the amended paragraph 23E(2)) at aquariums, zoos, safari parks, farms, wildlife centres and any place where animals are exhibited to the public as an attraction. From1 June, aquariums, zoos, safari parks, farms, wildlife centres were added to the list of attractions that must be closed, but from 15 June they can now open, with the exception of any ‘indoor attractions’ (as defined). [Confused? Well I confess that I am.] Indoor attractions must also remain closed at visitor attractions such as botanical or other gardens, biomes or greenhouses; heritage sites or film studios and landmarks, including observation wheels or viewing platforms.
The prohibitions in paragraphs 21, 22 and 23 have been removed, so that it is now lawful to open all types of outdoor market, car showrooms and auction houses.
Although libraries must remain closed, this does not prevent the library from carrying on a business of offering goods for sale or for hire in a shop which is separate from the premises usually used for the provision of library services (“the library premises”); nor does it prevent the making deliveries in any way permitted under the rule mentioned above allowing shops to carry on remote ordering and delivery services; and neither does it prevent a library from operating a café or restaurant solely to sell food or drink for consumption off the premises, if the café or restaurant is separate from the library premises.
Places of worship must remain closed for public worship, but are now permitted (in addition to providing for funerals, broadcasting an act of worship, whether over the internet or as part of a radio or television broadcast, certain essential voluntary services or urgent public support services, as specified in the Regs) to be open for private prayer by individuals, i.e. prayer which does not form part of communal worship. Furthermore, a place of worship is permitted to carry on a business of offering goods for sale or for hire in a shop which is separate from the place of worship, and to make deliveries or otherwise provide services in response to orders received by the means mentioned above (i.e. online, by phone or by post). A place of worship may also operate a café or restaurant solely to sell food or drink for consumption off the premises, if the café or restaurant is separate from the place of worship.
For these purposes, a shop, café or restaurant is separate from a place of worship or library premises if it is a self-contained unit, and provided also that it is possible for a member of the public to enter the shop or café from a place outside the place of worship or library premises. It should perhaps be emphasised that the amended regulations do not permit a use of any premises that is not already authorised under the planning legislation; nor do they permit such a use in breach of any planning condition, enforcement notice or other legal constraint on such development.
There are also changes to the list of premises in Schedule 2 that must remain closed. The most important change is the complete removal of Part 3 (which was the part of the schedule that listed premises that could remain open for business), consequent upon the amendment of Regulation 5(1), which now prohibits only the provision of library services (with the exception mentioned above).
Oh, I almost forgot; you will be delighted to know that the prohibition on gyms and other sports facilities no longer extends to facilities for training for elite athletes (including indoor fitness studios, gyms, sports courts, indoor or outdoor swimming pools and other indoor leisure centres). But before any of you sporty types get overenthusiastic about this, the definition of ‘elite athletes’ is confined to those officially in the running for the British Olympic Team, or at a similar high level in their sports.
And finally, don’t get too used to the rules outlined above, because they are liable to change again in less than three weeks’ time, if the government decides that it’s safe to further relax the coronavirus lockdown. (Alternatively, if recent public behaviour leads to an increase in the rate of infection, rather than a continuing decrease, this could prompt a tightening of restrictions instead.)
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Thursday, 14 May 2020
Meet the authors: FREE planning law webinars
I’m pleased to be able to let readers of this blog know about a series of four free 'meet the author' planning law webinars that BATH PUBLISHING are broadcasting during May and June. You can listen in to one, two or all four absolutely free, gratis and for nothing!
In each webinar, one of Bath Publishing’s authors will provide a brief review of recent developments and cases and then open proceedings to questions from fellow panellists and the audience.
The series kicks off a week today, on Thursday 21 May with The Environment Bill – what it means for planners & developers by Tom Graham, who will provide a quick introduction to the impact that the Environment Bill will have on planning and development decisions. Tom’s book on the Bill will be published soon after it has received Royal Assent later this year. He also runs a Planning & Environment blog (to which I have just added a link on the sidebar).
I shall then be presenting the second in the series on Thursday 28th May. This will be a Permitted Changes of Use update, when I shall be highlighting some of the recent changes affecting permitted development that have occurred since publication of the Third Edition of my book, A Practical Guide to Permitted Changes of Use last October.
Among the topics I am hoping to cover will be:
• ‘Qualifying’ purpose for PD (New World Pay Phones – Court of Appeal)
• Extending the 56-day period (Gluck v SSHCLG, reversing the Warren Farm judgment)
• “Used solely for agriculture when last in use”, discussing
(a) whether a material change of use is required in order to override a former agricultural use, and
(b) whether it applies in any event after 20 March 2013
• Plans and drawings required for prior approval applications.
There will also be time to put questions to me and to an expert panel if you join us live.
On Thursday 4 June, Peter Edwards of Planning Progress will present a webinar on “Neighbourhood Planning - Key Questions Answered, when he will review some of the key questions for planners, local authorities and parish councils to consider when preparing a neighbourhood plan. Peter is the author of The Power of Neighbourhood Planning (which is due to be published during May).
Peter is the latest recruit to Bath Publishing’s stable of planning law authors. He is a solicitor specialising in planning and related aspects of law. He also runs Planning Progress Limited, a planning and public affairs consultancy that advises a variety of clients from all sectors, and throughout the UK, on planning and the interaction between planning and the environment. He advises a number of parish councils on all aspects of neighbourhood planning.
Finally, on Thursday 11 June, Alistair Mills of Landmark Chambers will present an NPPF Update. Alistair is the author of Interpreting the NPPF. In this webinar, he will update you on the latest policy developments and cases involving the NPPF, and will then take questions from the audience.
As well as being a busy member of the bar, Alistair is an External College Lecturer in Law at Magdalene College, Cambridge, and is an Assistant Editor of the Encyclopedia of Planning Law and Practice. He also maintains a digest of decisions relating to the NPPF on the Landmark Chambers website.
The timing of these seminars varies, so please be sure to check the time that they are due to go out on the relevant date. Full details can be seen on the Bath Publishing website [ https://bathpublishing.com/blogs/what-were-up-to/meet-our-planning-law-authors-free-webinars ] , where you can register to join one or more (or even all four) of these webinars.
We look forward to seeing you.
© MARTIN H GOODALL
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)